California Eases Off Legal Threats Over GOP Unauthorized Ballot Drop Boxes

Enlarge this image

A voter places a ballot in an official mail-in ballot drop box outside of the L.A. County Registrar’s office on October 14. The California Republican Party has said it will not comply with a state cease-and-desist order to halt usage of the GOP’s unofficial ballot drop boxes.

Mario Tama/Getty Images

hide caption

toggle caption

Mario Tama/Getty Images

2020 Election: Secure Your Vote
In Swing States, Officials Struggle To Process Ballots Early Due To Strict Local Laws

But while the California Republican Party agreed to not place unauthorized ballot drop boxes outdoors, leave drop boxes unattended or present them as official, the party says it will continue to accept ballots delivered by voters to local party offices and secure them in boxes attended by staff or volunteers.

Becerra and Padilla said they would continue to monitor the party’s activities closely and proceed with an investigation.

«The Republican Party’s deployment of these unofficial and deceptive ballot drop boxes were in violation of state law and they created voter confusion,» Padilla said.

In a statement on Twitter on Friday, the party’s spokesperson, Hector Bajaras, said the California Republican Party made no concessions to the attorney general or secretary of state and denied doing anything wrong in the first place.

2020 Election: Secure Your Vote
Despite Surge In Volunteers, Some Swing States Still Need Poll Workers

«This is a thuggish voter intimidation and vote suppression tactic by our Democratic Attorney General and Secretary of State,» he said.

Friday’s press conference left a lot of ambiguity about how the party is continuing to deploy ballot collection boxes and whether or not using unauthorized drop boxes in any form violates California law.

Padilla and Becerra reiterated that while ballot collection is allowed, state rules require that whoever assists with delivering a ballot sign the envelope to record a chain of custody. But they also said ballots without that signature would not be rejected, either.

The stance was a departure from the forceful language of Monday’s cease and desist order, which demanded all ballots delivered to the unofficial drop boxes be surrendered to county election officials.

2020 Election: Secure Your Vote
Key Legal Fights Over Voting Remain Unresolved As Election Day Draws Close

The attorney general has issued subpoenas seeking the number and exact locations of ballot boxes deployed by the state Republican Party, information demanded in the cease and desist letter, which the party has refused to disclose.

The original boxes in question appeared at churches, gun stores and gas stations in Fresno, Orange and Los Angeles counties and raised red flags among county election officials and voters unsure of their legitimacy.

Earlier this week, a GOP spokesperson declined to tell the Orange County Register an exact number of these drop boxes, but placed the figure at over 100.

Following the order to remove the boxes, the state Republican party called the Democratic reaction «overblown» and insisted the boxes were a legitimate way to collect ballots.

«Democrats are now upset because organizations, individuals and groups are offering an opportunity for their friends, family, and patrons to drop off their ballot with someone they know and trust,» the California GOP tweeted.

“In California, where you can have convicted felons and individuals with a criminal history go door to door and collect ballots from voters, Democrats are now upset because organizations, individuals and groups are offering an opportunity for their friends, family, and patrons… pic.twitter.com/Ljx3WOldmd

— CAGOP (@CAGOP) October 12, 2020

The party cited «ballot harvesting,» a practice also known as «ballot collection,» which enables voters to designate an individual to collect and return their ballot for them.

According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, 26 states, including California, allow some form of this practice, with various limitations on how many ballots a designee can collect and who that designee can be.

2020 Election: Secure Your Vote
Fewer People May Vote By Mail Than Expected. That Could Mean Election Day ‘Chaos’

Earlier this week, Padilla, the secretary of state, sent a memo to county election officials flagging Elections Code section 3011 (a)(11), which states a designee must include their signature on the return vote-by-mail envelope as the person authorized to return the ballot, along with providing their name and relationship to the voter.

«When a voter drops off a ballot in an unauthorized, non-official vote-by-mail drop box, no designated ‘person’ would be signing, as required by state law,» the memo added.

Tom Hiltachk, the state party’s general counsel, disputed Padilla’s characterization of the election law during a call with reporters on Wednesday, saying Padilla doesn’t address a subdivision that reads, «a ballot shall not be disqualified solely because the person authorized to return it did not provide on the identification envelope his or her name, relationship to the voter, or signature.»

Padilla acknowledged that provision during Friday’s press conference, saying the state would not punish a voter over the actions of the state party.

Hiltachk noted that it was «perhaps an overzealous volunteer» who affixed the «official» label to what he says was only a handful of boxes.

«That was unfortunate but that was dealt with within hours and we’re not attempting to describe these as official boxes. They’re simply just a vehicle for us to take ballots and secure them until we can deliver them to elections officials,» Hiltachk said.

To further complicate matters, the Republican party’s efforts in California flies in the face of the Republican’s national (and mostly unsuccessful) legal strategy: President Trump and the GOP have for months questioned the integrity of mail-in ballots and have been fighting in court against ballot drop boxes.